Islamic Art

Islamic Art

Conflict of interest management

Conflict of Interest Policy for Editorial Board Members

The joirnal of Islamic Art Studies is committed to upholding the highest ethical standards and ensuring integrity throughout its publication processes. In cases where editorial board members or staff are affiliated with multiple journals, clear policies have been established to manage potential conflicts of interest. All editorial members are required to disclose any possible conflicts of interest, including collaborations with other journals, financial or personal affiliations, or any relationship that may influence the impartiality and independence of editorial decisions.

These disclosures are reviewed on a regular basis to ensure that editorial judgments remain fair, objective, and consistent with principles of transparency and best practices in scholarly publishing. For further information regarding our procedures, please contact: int.islamicart@gmail.com

 

Conflict of Interest Policy for Authors

A conflict of interest refers to any situation that interferes—or could reasonably be perceived to interfere—with the complete, objective, and unbiased submission, evaluation, editorial decision-making, or publication of scholarly or non-scholarly work submitted to the journal of Islamic Art Studies, published by the Institute for Islamic Art Studies. A conflict of interest arises when professional judgment related to primary interests (such as research integrity) is influenced by secondary interests.

There is nothing inherently unethical about having competing interests; however, full transparency is required. All authors must disclose all potential conflicts of interest in their cover letter and within the “Conflict of Interest” section at the time of submission.

If no conflicts exist, the following statement must be included:

“The author(s) declare that there is no conflict of interest regarding the authorship or publication of this article.”

Editors may request additional information regarding potential conflicts. Editors and reviewers are also required to disclose any conflicts of interest. Individuals with conflicts will be removed from the review process. It is the policy of the Institute for Islamic Art Studies that none of the journal’s editors may have financial relationships with the authors.

Transparent disclosure of all conflicts of interest is essential to maintaining the integrity of research reporting. Failure to disclose conflicts may result in immediate rejection of the manuscript. If an undisclosed conflict of interest is discovered after publication, corrective actions will be taken. Conflicts of interest may be financial, non-financial, professional, or personal, and may arise in relation to an organization or an individual.

All disclosed conflicts must be published alongside the article. If a situation appears unclear or potentially indicative of a conflict, clarification must be sought. Any concerns regarding conflict of interest should be reported to the Editor-in-Chief or the journal office. The corresponding author may suggest potential reviewers at submission, but authors must avoid any inappropriate influence or conflict in selecting editors or reviewers. This applies not only to the corresponding author but to all co-authors.

Authors are expected to respect national interests and security considerations and to adhere to all relevant regulations in conducting their research.

Examples of Potential Conflicts of Interest

An author is affiliated with the same institution or organization as a reviewer or editor.

An author has served on the thesis committee of a reviewer or editor, or vice versa.

An author, reviewer, or editor has co-authored a publication within the past two years.

Authors must not recommend individuals who have read previous versions of the manuscript or who may be aware of the hypotheses, as this undermines the integrity of the blind review process.

Manuscripts submitted by authors affiliated with our institution or by members of the editorial board must be reviewed by external reviewers. Articles submitted by reviewers or editorial board members are evaluated independently and, if necessary, returned to the author for revision.

All authors, reviewers, and editorial board members must disclose any conflicts of interest (financial, personal, or professional), such as affiliations with cultural institutions or artistic projects. These disclosures are treated confidentially to preserve the impartiality of the publication process.

 

Financial Conflicts of Interest

Authors must disclose all funding sources in the manuscript before submission.

Financial conflicts of interest include—but are not limited to—the following:

Receiving reimbursement, compensation, grants, or salary from an organization that may benefit or incur financial loss from the publication of the article, now or in the future.

Holding shares or equity in an organization that may benefit or incur financial loss from the publication of the article.

Ownership of or application for patents related to the content of the submitted manuscript.

Receiving reimbursement, compensation, grants, or salary from an organization that owns or is applying for patents related to the manuscript content.

 

Non-Financial Conflicts of Interest

Non-financial conflicts of interest may include political, personal, ideological, academic, or intellectual interests, but are not limited to these categories.