نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
The present research aims to examine the function of Aristotelian catharsis and Brechtian alienation and to evaluate the capacity of these two frameworks in explaining the audience's experience in Iranian-Islamic Ta'ziyeh. The research employs a qualitative approach and a comparative-interpretive method; data were collected through documentary and library methods and examined through textual and conceptual analysis. In the first section, the concepts of catharsis, fear, pity, plot, recognition, and reversal in Aristotle's theory are analyzed with emphasis on Oedipus Rex. In the second section, alienation, the relationship between actor and role, interruption, montage, the revelation of theatrical convention, and the mode of audience encounter in Brecht's theater are examined, focusing on Mother Courage and Her Children and The Exception and the Rule. In the third section, the Ta'ziyeh of the Martyrdom of Imam Husayn (AS) is analyzed as an example of Iranian-Islamic ritual dramatic art and compared with the two aforementioned models. The findings indicate that emotion and cognition are present in both the Aristotelian and Brechtian models, but their organization and ultimate aim differ. In Ta'ziyeh, the audience's prior awareness of the outcome of the event, the distinction of the shabih-khan from the sacred persona, and the transparency of the theatrical convention do not prevent emotional affect and, simultaneously with collective mourning, function through Ashura memory and ritual participation. Therefore, the audience's experience in Ta'ziyeh cannot be explained by catharsis or alienation alone; rather, this experience is formed by the simultaneity of emotional affect, awareness of representation, performative distance, and ritual participation.
Research Objectives:
A comparative analysis of how the relationship among emotion, cognition, and the audience is organized in the Aristotelian model of catharsis and the Brechtian model of alienation.
Explaining the emotional-ritual experience of the audience in the Ta'ziyeh of the Martyrdom of Imam Husayn (AS) and assessing the capacities and limitations of Aristotelian catharsis and Brechtian alienation in explaining this experience.
Research Questions:
What distinctions and common aspects exist between Aristotelian catharsis and Brechtian alienation in how they organize the relationship among emotion, cognition, and the audience?
To what extent are Aristotelian catharsis and Brechtian alienation capable of explaining the emotional-ritual experience of the audience in the Ta'ziyeh of the Martyrdom of Imam Husayn (AS), and what distinction does this experience have with the two aforementioned models?
کلیدواژهها English